In England and Wales, the selection and appointment process for both superior and inferior judges is governed by the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC). The JAC is an independent body responsible for selecting candidates for judicial positions based on merit.
Superior Judges
Qualifications: Superior judges, such as those in the High Court, Court of Appeal, and Supreme Court, are typically appointed from experienced barristers or solicitors who have practiced law for a significant period of time. They must have substantial legal qualifications, expertise, and a proven track record in the legal profession.
Application or nomination: When a vacancy arises, the JAC publicly advertises the position and invites applications or nominations. The advertisement includes the necessary qualifications, experience, and personal qualities required for the position.
Selection process: The JAC uses a rigorous selection process to assess candidates' suitability for the judicial role. This process includes a detailed application form, a comprehensive assessment of candidates' competencies, and often a scenario-based written exercise.
Judicial interviews: Shortlisted candidates are invited to a judicial interview conducted by a panel of JAC commissioners. The interview aims to assess the candidates' legal knowledge, judgment, integrity, and ability to effectively carry out the judicial role.
Recommendation and appointment: Based on the assessment and interview, the JAC makes recommendations to the Lord Chancellor, who is responsible for making the final appointment. The Lord Chancellor may accept or reject the recommendation but must provide reasons for doing so.
Inferior Judges (Magistrates)
Qualifications: Magistrates are lay judges who do not require formal legal qualifications. They are appointed from the local community and are expected to possess qualities such as fairness, good character, common sense, and an understanding of society.
Application or nomination: The local advisory committee, known as the Advisory Committee on Justices of the Peace (ACJPs), oversees the selection process for magistrates. They invite applications or nominations for vacancies and may also actively seek potential candidates.
Selection process: The ACJPs conduct interviews and assessments to evaluate candidates' suitability for the magistracy. The selection process may include an assessment of candidates' personal qualities, judgment, understanding of the criminal justice system, and commitment to public service.
Recommendation and appointment: The ACJPs make recommendations to the Lord Chancellor, who appoints magistrates. The Lord Chancellor may consider the recommendations and may also seek the views of other local magistrates or community representatives before making the final appointment.
The appointment process for both superior and inferior judges in England and Wales aims to ensure transparency, fairness, and merit-based selection. The involvement of independent bodies like the JAC and ACJPs helps to maintain the integrity of the selection process and uphold the quality and independence of the judiciary.
Study with us to smash your AL/AS Law exam now:
