General principles of European Union law serve as foundational concepts applied by both the European Court of Justice and national courts within member states when assessing the legality of legislative and administrative measures. These principles, by design, are broad and open-ended, necessitating refinement for specific application rather than adherence to rigid rules of law. Their application spans various legal sources, including common legal principles in member states, international law, and EU law itself.
Fundamental Rights as Cornerstones: Fundamental rights hold a central position within the general principles of EU law. Article 6(3) of the Treaty on European Union explicitly acknowledges the significance of fundamental rights, affirming that these rights, as guaranteed by the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, constitute general principles of the Union's law. This recognition underscores the commitment to upholding human rights as an integral part of the EU legal framework.
Application in Non-Contractual Liability: The legal framework for non-contractual liability within the EU, as outlined in Article 340 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, explicitly allows for the application of "general principles common to the laws of the Member States." This provision underscores the versatility of general principles in addressing issues of liability beyond contractual relationships, ensuring their relevance in a variety of legal contexts.
Sources for Formulation: European Union judges tasked with applying general principles draw on a diverse array of sources. These include not only the principles inherent in public international law but also the national laws of member states, general principles inferred directly from EU law, and the fundamental human rights that underpin the legal systems across member states. This multi-sourced approach aims to create a robust and adaptable foundation for the interpretation and application of EU law.
Purpose and Application in EU Jurisprudence: The application of general principles in EU jurisprudence serves multiple purposes. Primarily, they prevent the denial of justice, ensuring fair and just legal outcomes. Additionally, general principles are instrumental in filling gaps within EU law, addressing situations where specific rules may be absent or insufficient. Moreover, they contribute to the overall coherence of EU law, providing a unifying framework that enhances the effectiveness and predictability of the legal system.
Accepted General Principles: Several general principles have gained acceptance within EU law. These include fundamental rights, emphasising the protection of individual liberties; proportionality, ensuring a balanced response to legal issues; legal certainty, providing predictability within the legal system; equality before the law, promoting fairness; and subsidiarity, delineating the appropriate level of decision-making within the EU's complex governance structure.
Precautionary Principle in EU Law: Illustrating the dynamic nature of general principles, the case of Artegodan (Case T-74/00) highlights the European Court of Justice's willingness to extrapolate from specific provisions, such as the precautionary principle in environmental policy (Article 191(2) TFEU), to a broader general principle of EU law. This flexibility allows the principles to evolve and adapt to emerging legal challenges, demonstrating their capacity to address novel issues within the EU legal framework.
In conclusion, the general principles of European Union law form a crucial and dynamic foundation that guides the interpretation and application of legal measures within the EU. Recognised by both the European Court of Justice and national courts, these principles, born from diverse legal sources, embody the fundamental values and rights that underpin the Union's legal framework. Whether addressing issues of fundamental rights, non-contractual liability, or gaps in legislation, these principles serve as adaptable tools, promoting justice, legal certainty, and coherence in the evolving landscape of EU law.
Check out our exam-focused EU Law notes now.
Subscribe to UOL Case Bank for more exclusive content and case summaries.
