Criminal Practice
Share
Criminal Practice is designed to provide students with an in-depth exploration of the practical aspects of criminal law, procedure, and litigation. This course aims to equip students with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate the complexities of criminal practice, from police investigations and prosecution to courtroom proceedings, sentencing, and appeals.
1. Criminal Procedure
This foundational topic lays out the entire roadmap of a criminal case, from the moment a crime is suspected to the final resolution. It examines the rules and regulations that govern how criminal investigations are conducted, how suspects are treated, how prosecutions are brought, and how trials and appeals are managed. This includes understanding the powers of the police, the rights of the accused, the roles of different actors in the criminal justice system (police, prosecutors, defence lawyers, judges, juries), and the timelines and processes involved at each stage. A thorough understanding of criminal procedure is crucial for anyone involved in criminal litigation as it dictates the permissible actions and ensures a fair process.
2. Arrival at Police Station
This focuses on the critical initial stages when a suspect arrives at a police station, either voluntarily or under arrest. It covers the legal obligations of the police upon arrival, including the issuing of cautions (explaining the right to silence and the potential use of statements as evidence), informing the suspect of their rights to legal advice, and initiating the custody record. This topic also explores the suspect's rights at this stage, such as the right to have someone informed of their arrest and the right to consult privately with a solicitor. Understanding the correct procedures at this point is vital as any breaches can have significant consequences for the admissibility of later evidence.
3. Police Interviews
This delves into the complex and crucial process of police questioning of suspects. It examines the rules governing the conduct of interviews, including the Codes of Practice under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE), which aim to ensure fairness and prevent oppressive questioning. Key aspects include the appropriate environment for interviews, the recording of interviews, the provision of breaks and refreshments, and the role of the suspect's solicitor during the interview. This topic also explores issues surrounding confessions, their admissibility in court, and challenges to their reliability based on the conduct of the interview.
4. Identification Procedures
This area focuses on the various methods police use to identify suspects, ensuring accuracy and fairness to avoid miscarriages of justice. It covers procedures such as identification parades (line-ups), video identification, group identification, and showing photographs. The topic examines the strict rules and guidelines that govern these procedures under PACE Codes of Practice, emphasising the need for impartiality, minimising suggestion, and ensuring the suspect's rights are protected. Understanding the potential pitfalls and legal challenges to identification evidence is crucial in criminal practice.
5. Police Charge
This topic examines the point at which the police decide that there is sufficient evidence to formally accuse a suspect of a crime. It covers the process of formulating the charge(s), ensuring they accurately reflect the alleged offending behaviour and comply with legal requirements. The topic also addresses the information that must be provided to the suspect upon being charged, including the details of the offence and the next steps in the legal process. Understanding the implications of a charge and the options available to the accused at this stage is fundamental.
6. Vulnerable Clients
This crucial area focuses on the specific considerations and legal safeguards that apply when dealing with vulnerable individuals within the criminal justice system. This includes those with mental health issues, learning disabilities, youths, and others who may have difficulty understanding or participating effectively in the legal process. The topic examines the enhanced duties of the police and legal representatives towards vulnerable clients, including the provision of appropriate support, the use of intermediaries to facilitate communication, and ensuring their rights are fully protected. Understanding how to effectively represent and safeguard the interests of vulnerable clients is a vital ethical and practical aspect of criminal practice.
7. Funding Criminal Litigation
This practical topic explores the different ways in which criminal cases are funded in the UK. It primarily focuses on Legal Aid, examining the eligibility criteria, the application process, and the different types of Legal Aid available for advice, assistance, and representation in court. The topic also touches upon private funding options and the implications of funding on a client's access to justice and their relationship with their legal representatives. Understanding the complexities of funding is essential for practitioners to advise their clients and manage their cases effectively.
8. Initial Hearing
This covers the first appearance of a defendant in court after being charged. It examines the procedures that take place at this hearing, which typically include confirming the defendant's identity, reading the charge(s, entering a plea (if applicable in summary cases), and making decisions regarding bail or remand. The topic also explores the roles of the prosecution and defence at this stage and the importance of providing early legal advice to the defendant. Understanding the dynamics and potential outcomes of the initial hearing is crucial for setting the stage for the rest of the case.
9. Bail
This focuses on the process of deciding whether a defendant should be released from custody pending their trial or further court appearances. It examines the legal principles governing bail applications, the factors the court must consider (such as the risk of absconding, committing further offences, or interfering with witnesses), and the conditions that can be attached to bail (e.g. reporting to a police station, surrendering passport, curfew). The topic also covers the process of applying for bail, appealing bail decisions, and the responsibilities of a surety. Understanding bail law and advocacy is a critical skill for criminal practitioners.
10. Preparation for Trial
This encompasses the extensive work undertaken by both the prosecution and the defence in the lead-up to a criminal trial. It examines key aspects such as gathering and reviewing evidence, interviewing witnesses, preparing witness statements, drafting legal documents, identifying potential legal arguments, and developing trial strategy. This topic emphasises the importance of thoroughness, organisation, and effective communication in building a strong case. Understanding the intricacies of trial preparation is essential for successful advocacy.
11. Criminal Evidence
This core topic delves into the rules governing the admissibility of evidence in criminal proceedings. It examines different types of evidence (e.g. witness testimony, documents, real evidence, hearsay, confessions, bad character evidence), the principles of relevance and admissibility, and the legal tests that must be satisfied for evidence to be presented in court. Understanding the law of evidence is fundamental for both prosecution and defence lawyers to effectively present their case and challenge the evidence of the opposing side.
12. Advocacy Technique
This focuses on the practical skills required to effectively present a case in court. It covers a range of techniques, including opening and closing speeches, examination-in-chief, cross-examination, and re-examination of witnesses. The topic emphasises the importance of clear communication, persuasion, strategic questioning, managing exhibits, and responding effectively to judicial interventions. Developing strong advocacy skills is crucial for effectively representing clients and presenting legal arguments in a compelling manner.
13. Summary Trial
This examines the procedures for trials of less serious offences that are heard in the Magistrates' Court without a jury. It covers the flow of a summary trial, including the prosecution's case, the defence case, the presentation of evidence, and the magistrates' decision on guilt or innocence and sentencing (if applicable). Understanding the specific rules and practices of summary trials is essential for practitioners who regularly appear in the Magistrates' Court.
14. Trial on Indictment
This focuses on the procedures for trials of more serious offences that are heard in the Crown Court before a judge and jury. It covers the various stages of an indictment trial, including jury selection, the prosecution's opening speech, the presentation of prosecution evidence, the defence case, closing speeches, the judge's summing up, and the jury's deliberations and verdict. Understanding the complexities of Crown Court trials is crucial for those involved in representing clients facing serious criminal charges.
15. Sentencing
This topic explores the principles and processes involved in determining the appropriate sentence for a convicted offender. It examines the different types of sentences available to the courts (e.g. imprisonment, community orders, fines, suspended sentences), the factors the court must consider when sentencing (e.g., the seriousness of the offence, the offender's background, mitigating and aggravating factors), and the aims of sentencing (e.g. retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, protection of the public). Understanding sentencing law and advocacy is vital for both prosecution and defence in ensuring fair and appropriate outcomes.
16. Criminal Appeals
This examines the procedures for challenging decisions made by criminal courts. It covers the different routes of appeal from the Magistrates' Court and the Crown Court, the grounds on which an appeal can be made (e.g. errors of law, procedural irregularities, unreasonable verdicts, excessive sentences), and the powers of the appellate courts. Understanding the law and practice of criminal appeals is crucial for ensuring that potential miscarriages of justice can be addressed.
17. Youth Court Procedure
This focuses on the specific rules and procedures that apply when dealing with children and young people within the criminal justice system. It examines the distinct principles and objectives of the Youth Court, the modified procedures for hearings involving young defendants, the roles of parents and guardians, and the sentencing options available for young offenders. Understanding Youth Court procedure is essential for practitioners who represent young clients and for ensuring their welfare and rehabilitation are properly considered.
In conclusion, this module equips students with essential knowledge of the criminal justice system, covering procedures from investigation to appeals. It delves into the roles of key actors like police and prosecutors, and the processes of both less serious (summary) and more serious (indictable) trials. Through examining sentencing and appeal mechanisms, you develop a comprehensive understanding of effective criminal practice.
