Essential Validity vs Formal Validity
Share
Formal validity and essential validity are two distinct concepts in the context of marriage.
Formal validity refers to the procedural requirements that must be met for a marriage to be considered legally binding. These requirements may include obtaining a marriage license, having witnesses present, or conducting the ceremony in a particular location. Failure to meet these formal requirements can result in the marriage being considered voidable, but it does not necessarily mean that the marriage is invalid from the outset.
Essential validity, on the other hand, refers to the fundamental requirements that must be met for a marriage to be considered legally valid. These requirements may include legal age, capacity, consent, and the absence of any legal impediments to the marriage. Failure to meet these essential requirements can result in the marriage being considered void, which means that it is invalid from the outset.
To illustrate the difference between formal validity and essential validity, consider the example of a couple who gets married without obtaining a marriage certificate. In this case, the marriage may be considered voidable due to the failure to meet the formal requirement of obtaining a license. However, if one of the parties was already married to someone else at the time of the second marriage, the marriage would be considered void due to the failure to meet the essential requirement of the absence of any legal impediments to the marriage.
In summary, formal validity refers to procedural requirements for a valid marriage, while essential validity refers to fundamental requirements for a valid marriage. Failure to meet formal requirements may result in a voidable marriage, while failure to meet essential requirements results in a void marriage.
Formal validity refers to the procedural requirements that must be met for a marriage to be considered legally binding. These requirements may include obtaining a marriage license, having witnesses present, or conducting the ceremony in a particular location. Failure to meet these formal requirements can result in the marriage being considered voidable, but it does not necessarily mean that the marriage is invalid from the outset.
Essential validity, on the other hand, refers to the fundamental requirements that must be met for a marriage to be considered legally valid. These requirements may include legal age, capacity, consent, and the absence of any legal impediments to the marriage. Failure to meet these essential requirements can result in the marriage being considered void, which means that it is invalid from the outset.
To illustrate the difference between formal validity and essential validity, consider the example of a couple who gets married without obtaining a marriage certificate. In this case, the marriage may be considered voidable due to the failure to meet the formal requirement of obtaining a license. However, if one of the parties was already married to someone else at the time of the second marriage, the marriage would be considered void due to the failure to meet the essential requirement of the absence of any legal impediments to the marriage.
In summary, formal validity refers to procedural requirements for a valid marriage, while essential validity refers to fundamental requirements for a valid marriage. Failure to meet formal requirements may result in a voidable marriage, while failure to meet essential requirements results in a void marriage.
