Orientating Perspectives in Studying Crime
Share
In studying crime, various orienting perspectives or theoretical frameworks can provide different lenses through which researchers and scholars understand and analyse criminal behaviour, its causes, and its consequences. Two such perspectives are correctionalism and appreciation.
Correctionalism
Correctionalism, also known as positivism or the positivist approach, emphasises the scientific study of crime and focuses on identifying the causes and correlates of criminal behaviour. It seeks to understand crime through empirical evidence, data analysis, and the application of scientific methodologies. Key features of correctionalism include:
Determinism: Correctionalism posits that criminal behaviour is determined by various factors, such as biological, psychological, or social factors. It assumes that individuals may be predisposed to criminal behaviour due to inherent traits or external influences.
Risk factors and predictive models: Correctionalism seeks to identify risk factors associated with criminal behaviour, such as genetic factors, childhood experiences, or social environments. It aims to develop predictive models that can assess an individual's likelihood of engaging in criminal activity.
Treatment and rehabilitation: Correctionalism emphasises the importance of interventions aimed at rehabilitation, addressing the underlying causes of criminal behaviour, and reducing recidivism. It supports evidence-based approaches, such as cognitive-behavioural therapy or educational programs, to prevent future criminal involvement.
Appreciation
Appreciation, also known as constructionism or the social constructionist approach, focuses on the subjective and socially constructed nature of crime and criminal behaviour. It emphasises the role of societal and cultural factors in defining and responding to crime. Key features of appreciation include:
Social context: Appreciation recognises that crime is shaped by social, cultural, and historical contexts. It explores how societal norms, values, and power dynamics influence the definition of crime and the labelling of individuals as criminals.
Language and symbolism: Appreciation examines how language, discourse, and symbolic representations influence the perception and understanding of crime. It highlights the role of media, political rhetoric, and public narratives in shaping public opinion and responses to crime.
Power and inequality: Appreciation emphasises the significance of power relations and social inequalities in the study of crime. It explores how factors such as race, class, gender, and privilege intersect with the criminal justice system, influencing processes of criminalisation, punishment, and social control.
Social movements and activism: Appreciation encourages engagement with social movements and activism aimed at challenging unjust systems and promoting social change. It recognises the importance of grassroots movements in advocating for alternative responses to crime and addressing structural injustices.
Both correctionalism and appreciation offer valuable insights and perspectives in understanding crime. They highlight different aspects of criminal behaviour, focusing on scientific explanations and individual rehabilitation (correctionalism) or the social and cultural context and the impact of power structures (appreciation). Integrating multiple perspectives can lead to a more comprehensive understanding of crime and inform policies and interventions that address its complex nature.
Correctionalism
Correctionalism, also known as positivism or the positivist approach, emphasises the scientific study of crime and focuses on identifying the causes and correlates of criminal behaviour. It seeks to understand crime through empirical evidence, data analysis, and the application of scientific methodologies. Key features of correctionalism include:
Determinism: Correctionalism posits that criminal behaviour is determined by various factors, such as biological, psychological, or social factors. It assumes that individuals may be predisposed to criminal behaviour due to inherent traits or external influences.
Risk factors and predictive models: Correctionalism seeks to identify risk factors associated with criminal behaviour, such as genetic factors, childhood experiences, or social environments. It aims to develop predictive models that can assess an individual's likelihood of engaging in criminal activity.
Treatment and rehabilitation: Correctionalism emphasises the importance of interventions aimed at rehabilitation, addressing the underlying causes of criminal behaviour, and reducing recidivism. It supports evidence-based approaches, such as cognitive-behavioural therapy or educational programs, to prevent future criminal involvement.
Appreciation
Appreciation, also known as constructionism or the social constructionist approach, focuses on the subjective and socially constructed nature of crime and criminal behaviour. It emphasises the role of societal and cultural factors in defining and responding to crime. Key features of appreciation include:
Social context: Appreciation recognises that crime is shaped by social, cultural, and historical contexts. It explores how societal norms, values, and power dynamics influence the definition of crime and the labelling of individuals as criminals.
Language and symbolism: Appreciation examines how language, discourse, and symbolic representations influence the perception and understanding of crime. It highlights the role of media, political rhetoric, and public narratives in shaping public opinion and responses to crime.
Power and inequality: Appreciation emphasises the significance of power relations and social inequalities in the study of crime. It explores how factors such as race, class, gender, and privilege intersect with the criminal justice system, influencing processes of criminalisation, punishment, and social control.
Social movements and activism: Appreciation encourages engagement with social movements and activism aimed at challenging unjust systems and promoting social change. It recognises the importance of grassroots movements in advocating for alternative responses to crime and addressing structural injustices.
Both correctionalism and appreciation offer valuable insights and perspectives in understanding crime. They highlight different aspects of criminal behaviour, focusing on scientific explanations and individual rehabilitation (correctionalism) or the social and cultural context and the impact of power structures (appreciation). Integrating multiple perspectives can lead to a more comprehensive understanding of crime and inform policies and interventions that address its complex nature.